Monday, January 20, 2020

Walker-Elders B2 - BIM for Architects and Engineers


Building Integrated Modeling (BIM) has had a dramatic impact on the way buildings are designed from concept to construction. Using BIM, designers are more capable of considering every aspect of a building holistically, instead of trying to imagine how three-dimensional systems will interact, using only two-dimensional space to design in. The utilization of BIM leads designers to consider architectural, structural, MEP (mechanical, electrical, and plumbing), and constructability of a building, which allows architects and engineers to catch design flaws before they become a major issue for the project. 

The utilization BIM creates a centralized model system where separate engineering disciplines can work in the same model, and see issues that arise from other design considerations. By the engineering disciplines having more communication in the early phases of project design, this can avoid potentially costly, and time-wasting problems that could arise later in the design or construction phases of a project. BIM supports engineering integration by creating a "workbench integration" of tools used interdisciplinarily, for architects, engineers, CMs, and subcontractors to all have access to.  

Depending on the project's contract, the design process can look very different from project to project. In a "standard" design-bid-build contract procurement, the architect, engineer, and construction manager may work very little with each other and take a few considerations for the difficulties across disciplines. However, BIM can really lend itself to newer types of contract procurement such as design-build or integrated project delivery (IPD) method, where the disciplines all work more closely together. These are especially useful when through the same models, an architect or engineer can take a concept model, and through considerable development of specifications and details, form a working construction model. Having all necessary information in a centralized model can limit the confusion of which documents are the correct draft to build from. Utilizing BIM through the construction phase also can specify specific workflows depending on the building type and any considerations needed for a specific project. 

As with any major technology shift in any industry, the hardest part of implementing BIM for architects and engineers is the industry-wide adoption. This crucial step is hypothetically easy, but much more difficult in actuality. The technology for BIM can be out there, but if architects and engineers aren't ready to learn and implement the software to its fullest potential, it will be implausible to see that the benefits possible for this industry. 

Source:

Eastman, Chuck, et al. BIM Handbook: A Guide to Building Information Modeling for Owners, Designers, Engineers, Contractors, and Facility Managers, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated, 2018. ProQuest Ebook Central, http://ebookcentral.proquest.com/lib/drexel-ebooks/detail.action?docID=5447327.


Comments: 


Amanda,

I liked your insights on the role of Facilities Management using BIM to track their projects and manage costs of building maintenance. BIM seems like such a good tool for owner and Facilities Managers to use in the maintenance of their buildings, especially as the life expectancy of buildings extend as well. I think what would be most beneficial for owners and FMs is if there was an easy way to make models for buildings that already exist, with all the details and specifications of new buildings, so that larger companies with many buildings could manage all of the buildings on the same platform.

Ina, 
I believe that the concept of interoperability is what will continue to help the integration of BIM systems to older buildings that have were built before BIM was a technology. For instance, I work at a hospital, and all of our buildings that predate 2015 do not have any Revit models associated with them because it was before that technology was really popular. But if we could take the CAD files and translate them to Revit retroactively, it would be a lot easier than having to redraw the entire building from scratch in Revit.

Spencer,

I really like your section on the history of modeling because I think it is important to understand where we have come from in order to appreciate what we have now. I think that having perspective for when we are frustrated that software isn't working the way we expect it to, or if we are having trouble modeling a certain thing using it, that these are technologies that didn't exist 50 years ago. The development of these softwares are always evolving and I'm sure that as our professional careers progress, we will see all sorts of changes that we cannot even imagine now.

4 comments:

Dane Bell said...

Madeleine
I wrote a very similar analysis but from a completely different section. Most of my points were analogous to yours as well, including the idea that multiple disciplines should be taking part in the design process to eliminate unforeseen problems, overlap and confusion. You however, said that the different disciplines should have the same tools which I assume means teaching civil and structural engineers revit or architects microstation or cad. I appreciate how you explain that the it should be easy to convert everyone to one program but is basically impossible because nobody likes change, apparently. Sorry I don’t have any contradictory points, but we happened to land on adjacent conclusions.

Manon Flamini said...

Maddie,

You make a great point about the advantages of using BIM during the conceptual phase of a project. It is important that all participants of a project communicate with each other early on in order to maximize the building's performance. I agree with you that it is hypothetically easy to consider a more collaboratively environment between architects and engineers, but that this is something that we still don't see implemented. I think people in our industry like to stick to what they are used to instead of trying new methods, which needs to change in order to make new advancements in our fields.

cory said...

Maddie,
I Really liked your insights with regard to the usefulness of BIM in the in the process of building construction with regards to interdisciplinary cooperation. I feel that this is one of the main reasons that the use of BIM will become more standard in the construction industry as time moves on. The ability for a general contractor to see all work packages on one three dimensional building model is invaluable when it comes to scheduling work, and navigating the task of completing a large multifaceted project.

Michael Manley said...

I liked your ideas on the challenges that come with any major technology shift. Sometimes it is very hard to convince someone to do something a new way even if it is proven to be better! People often see no reason to change if what they are doing is working. This why the majority of companies who are very successful strive in innovative environments that are right on the technology curve.